Crewe Alexandra F.C.andGrimsby Town F.C.

• Anthony Elding2008–1026 apps2011–1359 apps
• Bill Gardner1931–3212 apps1925–2720 apps
• Billy Haydock1960–64142 apps1964–6521 apps
• Colin Cramb1999–0150 apps2004–0511 apps
• Darran Kempson2006–077 apps2010–1153 apps
• David Felgate197912 apps1985–8736 apps
• Gary Montgomery20022007–095 apps
• George Ratcliffe——
• Greg Pearson20129 apps2012–1312 apps
• Gregor Robertson2012–1432 apps2015–16
• Harry Davis20102018–20
• Harry Mellor18952 apps1900–0133 apps
• Jimmy Pennington1960–6334 apps1963–6589 apps
• Marlon Broomes20098 apps200115 apps
• Nick Colgan19931994–1135 apps
• Paul Bignot2004–0721 apps2013–1537 apps
• Paul Holsgrove1997–988 apps199710 apps
• Riccardo Gabbiadini19902 apps1989–913 apps
• Rod Fletcher1966–671 apps1973–7512 apps
• Steve Saunders1985–8622 apps1987–8976 apps
• Thomas Elliott192416 apps1919
• Wes Fletcher2011–126 apps20106 apps

A dash means Wikidata holds no dates for that spell. It never means he did not play there.

Career data from Wikidata (CC0) and English Wikipedia.