Everton F.C. × Oldham Athletic A.F.C.
40 players have turned out for both clubs.
The 40 players
- Alan Shackleton1
- Anthony Gerrard2
- Asa Hartford3
- Benjamin Howard Baker4
- Billy Kenny5
- Bobby Collins6
- David Carney7
- David Irving8
- Dennis Stevens9
- Earl Barrett10
- Fred Kennedy11
- George Green12
- Glenn Keeley13
- Graeme Sharp14
- Ian Marshall15
- Ian Snodin16
- Jimmy Broad17
- Jimmy Harris18
- Joe Donnachie19
- Joe McBride20
- John Hurst21
- John Paul Kissock22
- Johnny Morrissey23
- Jose Baxter24
- Mark Ward25
- Martin Hodge26
- Mike Bernard27
- Mike Milligan28
- Neil Adams29
- Neil McDonald30
- Neil Moore31
- Neil Pointon32
- Paul Gerrard33
- Paul Wilkinson34
- Ray Wilson35
- Scott Spencer36
- Steven Schumacher37
- Stuart Barlow38
- Ted Taylor39
- Wilf Toman40